Bug #4413: resolve-uri() function also normalises consecutive spaces - Saxon - Saxonica Developer Community

Actions

Send by e-mail Copy link

Bug #4413

closed

resolve-uri() function also normalises consecutive spaces

Added by Matthew Hutchins almost 5 years ago. Updated almost 5 years ago.

Status:

Closed

Priority:

Low

Assignee:

Michael Kay

Category:

Sprint/Milestone:

Start date:

2019-12-18

Due date:

% Done:

Estimated time:

Legacy ID:

Applies to branch:

9.8

Fix Committed on Branch:

Fixed in Maintenance Release:

Platforms:

Description

Hi, Not sure if this is a bug or not. I have an application where I am making URLs from paths in the file system, using the resolve-uri() function. The issue is if a filename contains two consecutive spaces, the resolve-uri() function collapses these to a single space, and so the result URL does not work. I could not see anything in the documentation for this function that suggests this should happen. I have tested this using XSLT bundled with Oxygen XML 21, which is Saxon-PE 9.8.0.12 but have seen it in other versions too. I have attached a sample XSL file that demonstrates the problem. Note that the problem goes away if the file name is % encoded first, so maybe my issue comes from the fact that the space character isn't valid in the URI anyway.

Files

resolve-uri.xsl (651 Bytes) resolve-uri.xsl

Matthew Hutchins, 2019-12-18 00:21

Actions

Copy link

Updated by Michael Kay almost 5 years ago

I've reproduced this effect. Saxon is carefully escaping the spaces as %20 so that the Java JDK URI class doesn't barf on the URIs, and is then unescaping each %20 back to a space. The final step is to turn the resulting string into an instance of xs:anyURI, and it's at this stage that multiple spaces are being collapsed: the xs:anyURI type in XSD has the facet whitespace=collapse which means that the value space does not allow strings with consecutive spaces.

(XSD 1.1 part 2 is actually a bit inconsistent on this. It claims that the value space allows all sequences of characters, but by imposing the whiteSpace=collapse facet, it effectively constrains the value space. I've heard some XSD gurus say this is OK, the value space can include "ineffable" values that have no string representation; but this is hardly practical).

Given the fact that resolve-uri() is defined to return an xs:anyURI and that casting a string to xs:anyURI collapses whitespace, I don't think we can treat this as a bug, however inconvenient it might be.

Actions

Copy link